Netflix finds itself embroiled in a legal battle as Scottish woman Fiona Harvey sues the streaming giant and Baby Reindeer creator Richard Gadd for defamation, seeking $170 million in damages. Harvey alleges that her life has been irreparably harmed after being identified as the inspiration behind the stalker character Martha in the series.

The lawsuit contends that Netflix’s claim of the show being a “true story,” based on Gadd’s personal experiences, is false and has led to the dissemination of damaging falsehoods about Harvey’s character. While Harvey’s identity is not explicitly mentioned in the show, her lawyers argue that it is unmistakably linked to the character of Martha, portrayed by Jessica Gunning.

Harvey’s legal team asserts that Netflix failed to verify the events depicted in the series and perpetuated damaging lies about Harvey to millions of viewers worldwide. Allegations include portraying Harvey as a convicted stalker and a perpetrator of sexual assault, tarnishing her reputation and causing immense distress.

Netflix has faced similar defamation lawsuits in the past over portrayals in other productions, prompting scrutiny over the accuracy and ethical implications of their storytelling. Despite Gadd’s assertion that Baby Reindeer is emotionally authentic, Netflix maintains its stance to vigorously defend the lawsuit and uphold Gadd’s right to tell his story through the series.

Image via Netflix